Monday, August 22, 2011

Supreme Court to Revisit Eyewitness Identification - NY Times

34 Years Later, Supreme Court Will Revisit Eyewitness IDs

In November, the Supreme Court will return to the question of what the Constitution has to say about the use of eyewitness evidence. The last time the court took a hard look at the question was in 1977. Since then, the scientific understanding of human memory has been transformed.

Indeed, there is no area in which social science research has done more to illuminate a legal issue. More than 2,000 studies on the topic have been published in professional journals in the past 30 years.

What they collectively show is that it is perilous to base a conviction on a witness’s identification of a stranger. Memory is not a videotape. It is fragile at best, worse under stress and subject to distortion and contamination.

more on Eyewitness Misidentification from the Innocence Project

Read more about the case before the Supreme Court, Perry v. New Hampshire.